Worth County High School Students Sue Sheriff’s Office Over Invasive Search of Entire Student Body

Have you heard the one about the sheriff who walked into a high school? He frisked 900 students without a warrant and (in the majority of cases) without probable cause.

No, that’s not a joke, and no, that’s not the least bit funny. Unfortunately, it’s the reality of every student present at Worth County High School on April 14, 2017.

I first came across this situation this weekend in The Washington Post, though WALB has been covering it steadily in southwest Georgia for months. It seems that last March, some high school students were arrested on drug charges stemming from an incident that happened off campus. They told the sheriff, Jeff Hobby, that there were drugs at Worth County High School. Sheriff Hobby contacted the Sylvester Police Department, and the interim police chief, Gary Price, conducted a search on March 17. Chief Price found no drugs.

Unsatisfied and undeterred, Sheriff Hobby contacted Worth County High School to let them know there would be a search by his office “after spring break.” This brings us to April 14.

Sheriff Hobby told the school he would be searching 13 students who were suspected of trafficking drugs. Only three were at school that day, so they were called to an administrator’s office and searched. All of this was completely legal (and pretty standard).

Here’s where it goes awry.

According to student accounts and the accounts of school administrators, two dozen sheriff’s deputies entered the school, and the sheriff ordered the principal to put the school on lock down. Cell phones were seized to maintain a “blackout,” and for the next four hours, all students on campus were patted down. A lawsuit contends that students were taken from classrooms, spread against walls, and frisked, with many reports of deputies touching breasts and genitalia. Students were not allowed to leave, nor could they contact their parents. By the sheriff’s admission to WALB on April 17, one of his deputies got too aggressive in searching the students and “corrective action” was taken to ensure it wouldn’t happen again. However, the lawsuit has statements from students who were aggressively searched in different parts of the building, so it sounds like maybe it was more than one…

Can you guess what deputies recovered from the search? Not any drugs or even drug paraphernalia. Yes, seriously.

Hobby contends that the searches of all students were legal because an administrator was present. School officials disagree, stating that it was a warrantless search, and no case for probable cause for students beyond the initial 13 identified was presented. In a couple of articles I’ve read, the school district’s lawyer, Tommy Coleman, and the superintendent, Lawrence Walters, stated they believed what was happening was wrong, and it was far beyond any drug searches previously conducted by either the city police or county deputies. Coleman said to The Washington Post that school officials had no authority to stop the search.

I checked in with a couple of lawyers and a former sheriff’s deputy because that last statement didn’t sit well with me. Here’s what I learned: Georgia law constitutionally calls for the office of sheriff in each of our 159 counties and names the sheriff as the highest-ranking county official. That means that sheriffs’ offices are not departments of the county or city governments, and they are not beholden to them. (That would of course include the school district.) On the other hand, as a constitutional office, sheriffs are elected by the public to four-year terms and are thus beholden to their constituents to uphold the law. Yes, Georgia sheriffs have broad authority because of the way the office is laid out in the state constitution, but the officer and his or her deputies are also limited by the U.S. Constitution, and this could (and probably will) be classified as “unreasonable search and seizure” by the courts. The school system might not have authority over the sheriff’s office in Worth County, but as the only adults present during the incident — other than high school seniors who had had their 18th birthday — school administrators could have spoken up as constituents of the sheriff. I’ve learned that’s atypical, particularly in sparsely populated counties, as school officials prefer to have a cordial relationship with the sheriff’s office specifically because of its very broad authority. And I doubt, given what’s known about the search, students were allowed to refuse a search if they even knew they had the right to do so.

Separately, there has been no explanation for what the corrective action taken for the deputy was. By April 18, 30 parents had filed civil complaints with the Sylvester Police Department regarding the sheriff’s search. The Georgia Board of Education also received complaints but had no jurisdiction to act on them.

The NAACP and the Georgia Bureau of Investigation have now separately visited Sylvester to take statements from students who were searched. The GBI has at least one investigation open on the incident. The lawyers representing nine students, Mark Begnaud of Horsley Begnaud LLC and Crystal Redd of the Southern Center for Human Rights, hope to get the lawsuit reclassified as a class action lawsuit so they can represent all of the students affected.

There’s precedence for the class action route. A similar incident occurred at Stratford High School in Goose Creek, South Carolina, in 2003. In 2006, the sheriff’s office reached a class action settlement with payouts between $6,000 and $12,000 per student for the 150 students whose rights were violated. Imagine how expensive this is going to get for Worth County if history repeats itself.

11
Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
5 Comment threads
6 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
8 Comment authors
Holly CroftBenevolusSaltycrackerrickdayNoway2016 Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Dave Bearse
Dave Bearse

Get the checkbook out and order some more checks. They’re going to be some paydays.

And the Sherriff needn’t sweat that, based on Victor Hill’s experience.

jfkitchens
jfkitchens

Why do I have a vision of this Sheriff quoting line the “I am the Law” from the original Judge Dredd in full Stallone voice. Or maybe its more likely he was doing Cartman’s “respect my authoritah” while this search went on? I think I’m leaning towards the latter.

Progressive Dem
Progressive Dem

This is an egregious violation of civil liberties, a poorly trained and managed group of deputies, an excessive use of police force and a mismanagement of police resources. And the kicker is no drugs were found! How wrong can this sheriff be? Let’s hope the good people in Peanut Capital fire this goober at the next election.

Noway2016
Noway2016

Since this search will prove to have been illegal, I hope one of the kids, girl or boy, files criminal charges for sexual battery. This power- mad Buford T. Justice belongs in a cell, well before the next election.

Dave Bearse
Dave Bearse

Beyond that kicker there’s the kicker that when sheriff’s deputies next do stop and frisk, and actually find something, there’s viability to the defense that stop was unconstitutionally capricious.

rickday
rickday

“In order to protect the kids, we had to fondle them!”

And the War on (Some) Drugs trudges on….

Saltycracker
Saltycracker

The Sheriff may have fondled too many kids but the molesting will be the attorney’s cut of their judgement.

Benevolus
Benevolus

2 dozen deputies? How many deputies do they have in Worth County?

rickday
rickday

This is a major problem in the rural areas. Way too many law enforcement ratios per citizen covered. In Gilmer County, LE takes almost 65% of the county Budget, and between Ellijay PD, East Ellijay PD and Gilmer SD, we have 4.5 times the national average coverage of law enforcement (not first responders).

Gilmer County ranks first in all counties for DUI arrests. I’m sure it is just coincidence.

Our unofficial motto is “Come for vacation, leave with probation.”

This state desperately needs modernization from post Reconstruction 19th century.

Dave Bearse
Dave Bearse

Hey, this thing warranted overtime, what with Worth County’s thriving economy resulting in a County government flush with cash.